Few studies have reported the returntosport rate at 1year followup after primary and revision anterior cruciate ligament acl reconstruction. Acl reconstruction techniques aim to better restore the normal anatomy and biomechanics of the knee, and are hypothesized to potentially decrease the incidence of osteoarthritis after acl reconstruction. In 1995, it was reported that 60,000 to 75,000 anterior cruciate ligament acl reconstructions were being performed annually in the united states. The patient underwent acute acl reconstruction with a quadrupled hamstring tendon graft before achieving full extension. Multiplerevision acl reconstruction will have different characteristics than firsttime revision in terms of previous and current graft selection, mode of. Anterior cruciate ligament injuries one of the most common knee injuries is an anterior cruciate ligament sprain or tear.
After acl reconstruction, recurrent tears are seen in 14% to 28% of individuals with risk factors such as being younger than 18 years of age, engaging in pivot sports,,, and graft diameter below 8 mm. This type of injury is usually sports related requiring surgical intervention as a torn ligament will. To determine whether using 3dimensional 3dprinted models in addition to computed tomography ct scans to evaluate the primary femoral and tibial tunnels before revision anterior cruciate ligament acl reconstruction leads to better agreement with the surgical approach than ct alone. In this paper, the different aspects of anatomic acl reconstruction will be discussed. The knee is a simple hinge joint at the connection point between the femur and tibia bones. Acl reconstruction protocol south shore orthopedics. Schema of revision rectangular tunnel acl reconstruction with btb graft. Outcome of single bundle versus doublebundle reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament. Acl injuries most commonly occur during sports that involve sudden stops and changes in direction such as basketball, soccer, football, downhill skiing and gymnastics. Loss of knee extension has been shown to result in a limp, quadriceps muscle weakness, and anterior knee pain.
A and 6, secondary capsulitis acute surgery, resulting in loss of both extension and flexion. The epidemiology of revision anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in ontario, canada. Effect of graft choice on the outcome of revision anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in the multicenter acl revision study mars cohort. May 24, 20 revision reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament acl is becoming more frequent due to the increasing number of acl primary reconstruction combined with the high level of activity expected by the patients. Pdf download for revision anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction using a. The purpose of this metaanalysis was to determine overall objective graft failure rate, failure rate by graft type allograft vs autograft reconstruction, instrumented laxity, and patient outcome scores following revision anterior cruciate ligament acl reconstruction. Anterior cruciate ligament revision surgery poses a number of specific difficulties. It should be stressed that this is only a protocol and should not be a substitute for clinical decision making regarding a patients progression. Revision reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament acl is becoming more frequent due to the increasing number of acl primary reconstruction combined with the high level of activity expected by the patients. Does revision acl reconstruction measure up to primary. Twostage revision anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction knee. Number 1, march 2017 preoperative planning for acl revision surgery.
As they are such common injuries, acl reconstruction is one of the. Reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament acl is a surgery designed to restore knee stability and strength after the ligament has been torn. Although isolated hto with possible delayed acl reconstruction might be indicated in the older population, young active patients may require combined. It is held together by several important ligaments. Twostage revision anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Opening wedge high tibial osteotomy and anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction or revision. Return to sport after primary and revision anterior. Acl reconstruction information general information anterior cruciate ligament acl reconstruction is usually an outpatient procedure. Revision anterior cruciate ligament acl reconstruction is a technically demanding enterprise. Opening wedge high tibial osteotomy and anterior cruciate. Revision acl and pcl reconstruction musculoskeletal key. When there has been enough force to rupture the acl, there will be immediate pain in the knee. Pdf revision anterior cruciate ligament acl reconstruction is a technically demanding enterprise. Revision acl reconstruction using quadriceps or hamstring.
Revision anterior cruciate ligament acl reconstruction. Revision acl considerations southern california orthopedic. Revision anterior cruciate ligament surgery bernard r. Combined intra and extraarticular grafting for revision. Burnham, md uk orthopaedic surgery and sports medicine 2. Clinical outcomes in revision anterior cruciate ligament.
High tibial osteotomy hto is a valid treatment option for young active patients with medial tibiofemoral osteoarthrosis oa and varus deformity. Although primary acl reconstruction is a successful operation, success rates still range from 75%. Feb 24, 2016 surgical anatomical discoveries and growing understanding. Acl reconstruction is a surgical procedure to stabilise the knee by replacing the torn acl with ligament graft. Acl reconstruction adopted 398, revised 501, revised 204, revised 209 1 general principles. Rehabilitation protocol for anterior cruciate ligament. Dec 14, 2012 reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament acl is one of the most common surgical procedures, with more than 200,000 acl tears occurring annually. Knee acl reconstruction book 0415 twin cities orthopedics. Due to the increased importance of revision acl reconstruction, this study aims to evaluate the outcome 4 years after the surgery, compare two revision strategies and identify factors that influence the results.
Allograft for revision acl reconstruction request pdf. Acl reconstruction protocol1 northwestern medical center. Chapter 1 rehabilitation of revision acl reconstruction. With nonanatomic tunnels, which are seen most commonly, the technique of primary anatomic acl reconstruction can be employed without modification, while ensuring adequate bony bridge between tunnels. Click download or read online button to get acl book now. Pdf the evolution of acl reconstruction over the last fifty. Acl reconstruction rehabilitation protocol one of the most common complications following acl reconstruction is loss of motion, especially loss of extension. Anterior cruciate ligament acl rupture is a common sporting injury. Returntosport after acl revision reconstruction protocol this protocol is a criterionbased protocol, with a goal of maximizing healing and strength recovery, while minimizing risk of reinjury, so the athlete can return, as quickly and safely as possible, to athletic. Results after revision reconstruction are around 80% of return to high level sports. Sometimes medial oa is combined with symptomatic anterior cruciate ligament acl deficiency.
Graft selection autograft tissue is used most commonly but allografts and synthetics also are available autografts advantages low risk of adverse inflammatory reaction virtually no risk of disease transmission. Please note that any meniscal work can potentially alter the protocol. The acl is essential for normal knee function and stability. Similiar to the development in joint replacement surgery, revision surgery is becoming more and mo re important in anterior cruciate ligament acl. Johnson anterior cruciate ligament acl injuries are one of the most common sports injuries in the united states. This surgery is done at arthro health in east melbourne.
Anterior cruciate ligament revision reconstruction. In the absence of widening, anatomical tunnels may be reused in the revision reconstruction. Primary acl reconstructions are performed using different techniques, so the surgeon must take multiple factors into account when planning for the more complex procedure. Purpose to compare patientreported and clinicianreported outcomes, and radiographic results between patients who had had revision acl reconstruction and those who had had primary acl reconstruction. Although anterior cruciate ligament acl reconstruction has a high success rate, a substantial number of patients are left with unsatisfactory results. The evolution of acl reconstruction over the last fifty years. Indications for revision acl reconstruction request pdf.
Lateral extraarticular procedures in association with anterior cruciate ligament acl reconstruction can act as a protection against undesired loads occurring in the early postoperative phase. Expected immediate postoperative acl tunnel diameter should be around 10 mm regardless of graft selection. Lapradea comparison between a retrograde interference screw, suture button, and combined fixation on the tibial side in an allinside anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. All patients were assessed with an average followup of 4. Revision anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction surgery. Navigation for revision acl reconstruction springerlink. Oct 16, 2012 for additional information on revision acl reconstruction surgery, or to learn more about common knee injuries involving one or more ligaments within the knee, please contact the gulf breeze, florida orthopedic surgeon, dr. Anterior cruciate ligament acl and how do todays reconstruction techniques attempt to recreate it. What are possible technical complications associated with the reconstruction. When performing a revision reconstruction, the surgeon decides between a singlestage or a twostage revision. Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction, rehabilitation. Revision anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction using a 2. It should be stressed that this is only a protocol and should not be a substitute for clinical decision making. There is a growing appreciation for attempting to match native acl anatomy and function during its reconstruction or repair.
The most important of these to the knees stability is the anterior cruciate ligament acl. Revision anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with patellar tendon autograft. Medial meniscal strain is increased in acl deficiency greater laxity after acl r in patients with previous medial meniscectomy compared to intact menisci papageorgiou, et al, ajsm 2001 allen et al. Backgroundrevision anterior cruciate ligament surgery is often considered a. A strain to the acl is a more mild insult on the ligament and will not require surgical intervention. Acl reconstruction continues to be the most common, serious and controversial injury in orthopaedic sports medicine.
Longterm prognosis after acl reconstruction modern acl reconstruction techniques have about a 90% success rate, with about one in ten patients tearing the new acl graft like they injured their natural one. Reconstruction of the ruptured acl is accepted as standard treatment for athletes as it allows them to resume sporting activities. However, when compared to the standards of other orthopedics procedures today, acl reconstruction is not predictably successful in restoring patients to their preinjury state. More than 200,000 anterior cruciate ligament acl reconstructions are estimated to be performed annually in the united states. When tunnels are anatomic, evidence of tunnel widening must be considered. It runs diagonally through the inside of the knee and gives the knee joint stability. Combined anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction and. Panditrevision anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction using a 2stage technique with bone grafting of the tibial tunnel.
The surgeon uses a small video camera called an arthroscope to see inside the knee and make sure the new acl is positioned correctly. This study looked at the aetiology of primary acl graft failure and choices of graft used. Many failures are due to technical pitfalls and may be successfully addressed via revision acl reconstruction. Pdf revision acl reconstruction by hamstring tendon. Twostage anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Clinical and operative characteristics of cyclops syndrome after doublebundle anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction.
This technique has been proven in research to be the most minimally invasive technique available today and has been shown to have the least pain and quickest recovery of any acl surgical technique. Revision of anterior cruciate ligament acl reconstruction. Clinical guidelines for cpm following an acl reconstruction the primary goal of postsurgical rehabilitation following an acl reconstruction is to control pain, protect. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the function and clinical results of revision singlestage acl surgery using an anterolateral. Onestage revision anatomic anterior cruciate ligament. If you tear the anterior cruciate ligament acl in your knee, you may need to have reconstructive surgery. Acl reconstruction revision with staged bone grafting. Acl reconstruction surgery maribyrnong acl injury repair east. As a biological graft, an autograft undergoes revascularization and recollagenization but initial.
Outcome of a combined acl and all reconstruction with a. It is, therefore, important to follow a specific approach to evaluate, diagnose, and treat potential acl revision cases. Facts transformation of the graft into a strong and durable ligament requires four months. Revision anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with patellar. Anterior cruciate ligament acl revision rehabilitation protocol the following is a protocol for postoperative patients following acl reconstruction. Wilson is the only surgeon in the area performing allinside acl reconstruction. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. Most primary acl reconstruction surgeries have an 8090% success rate. With the rising number of anterior cruciate ligament acl reconstructions, revision acl reconstructions are becoming increasingly common. C, the quadrupled hamstring tendon acl graft has a normal mri appearance. The primary goal of this protocol is to protect the reconstruction while steadily progressing towards and ultimately achieving preinjury level of activity. The rest of the acl reconstruction will be performed with arthroscopic acl surgery, through small cuts on the sides of the knee. These include the lack of bone mass to enable effective fixation of the reconstruction, morbidity of the donor area when bone autograft is used to fill the tunnels, and absence of the semitendinosus and gracilis homolateral tendons in cases in which they have already been used in the primary surgical procedure.
Indications and technique provides detailed strategies for planning and executing revision acl reconstructions. A graft that stretches or ruptures during this time period is not repairable. Revision anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Pdf revision singlestage anterior cruciate ligament. When graft failure occurs, it is necessary to perform an acl revision procedure. There are different levels of severity of acl injuries. Returntosport after acl revision reconstruction protocol. Acl surgery has become progressively less invasive and more anatomic. The role of anatomic acl reconstruction in acl revision.
Revision anterior cruciate ligament surgery 115 figure 2. In the setting of a revision acl reconstruction, the risk of failure of an allograft is substantially higher than that of an autograft, especially in patients younger than 30 years of age. Revision surgery requires specialized techniques and instrumentation that we have optimized for our patients. With the knee bent, the damaged and torn acl is cleared away. Management of widened or previously malpositioned tunnels is challenging and often requires innovative approaches. Article information, pdf download for anterior cruciate ligament revision. This is a more challenging operation for the orthopedic surgeon. The 2 to 11year followup showed that the results of revision acl reconstruction with a nonirradiated patellar tendon allograft were less favorable than those of a primary anterior cruciate. Uk sports medicine conference revision anterior cruciate ligament acl reconstruction case presentation jeremy m. Shalvoy, md abstract anterior cruciate ligament acl injury and acl reconstruction is common in the united states. What is a current technique of an acl reconstruction and what is its rationale. Acl reconstruction adopted mar1998, revised jan2017 1 general principles. The lateral extraarticular tenodesis let procedure was initially developed as a treatment for anterior cruciate ligament acl insufficiency prior to the advent of modern acl reconstruction techniques. There are estimates that 100,000 new acl injuries occur annually.
This study aims to establish the current panorama of the anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. This protocol must be followed to prevent injury to the acl graft. Surgery is performed through one small incision about three inches in length in the front of. Acl reconstruction is surgery to replace a torn anterior cruciate kroosheate ligament acl a major ligament in your knee. Revision acl reconstruction causes of failure and graft. Fengclinical outcome of simultaneous high tibial osteotomy and anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction for medial compartment osteoarthritis in young patients with anterior cruciate ligament. Relevance of symptom pattern instability only optimum condition for revision surgery pain only revision for pain only results in unsatisfactory outcome rule out infection, arthrosis, chondral damage, meniscal insufficiency, or arthrofibrosis pain and instability pain from instability may be addressed by revision pain independent of instability. Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction rehabilitation. What is the history of acl reconstruction and its evolution.
Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction acl reconstruction is carried out after an injury to the anterior cruciate ligament. Acl reconstruction and rehabilitation 2 introduction deciding to have your acl ligament reconstructed is a big decision to make and will involve discussion between yourself, prof jari and your physiotherapist. Pdf revision of anterior cruciate ligament acl reconstruction. There seems to be a slow shift in choice of graft, as hamstring tendons are now. Concise chapters by a leading group of international. Acl runs diagonally in the middle of the knee, preventing the tibia from sliding out in front of the femur, as well as providing rotational stability to the knee. A revision procedure may be performed to improved knee function, correct instability, and facilitate a return to normal activities. Many factors contribute to successful acl reconstruction and rehabilitation, but failure of even one of these factors can lead to less than desirable outcomes. New techniques for anterior cruciate ligament revision surgery.
Clinical guidelines for cpm following an acl reconstruction. Autograft for anterior cruciate ligament revision surgery. Even after a successful reconstruction, it is possible to reinjure the acl. The surgeon must determine whether to perform a singlestage or 2stage revision when performing a revision acl reconstruction. Revision acl reconstruction a case presentation and. Anterior cruciate ligament acl reconstruction the knee doc. There were 33 revision acl reconstruction cases, for which followup was available for 29 88%. Revision acl reconstruction indications and technique. Seventynine patients who received a revision acl reconstruction were retrospectively evaluated. A revision acl reconstruction is a second surgery needed to repair a torn anterior cruciate ligament. The acl is a tough band of tissue joining the thigh bone to the shin bone at the knee joint. Anterior cruciate ligament acl reconstruction is an increasingly performed procedure that is now among the most common in sports surgery. Treatment for failed acl repair is complex and technically challenging, and the results of revision acl surgery are not as good as an initial acl reconstruction.
Eight hundred thirtythree replied giving a response rate of 20. To compare the returntosport rate 1 year after primary and revision acl reconstruction in the same cohort according to 2 modalities. Reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament acl is one of the most common surgical procedures, with more than 200,000 acl tears occurring annually. Revision reconstruction of the acl is becoming a common operation following the failure of primary graft. More than 200 000 anterior cruciate ligament acl injuries occur each year in the united states, and approximately 65% of these injuries are treated with reconstructive surgery. Median baseline marx interquartile range was 12 816 and 12 616 for the primary acl reconstruction and revision acl reconstruction groups respectively p0. Anterior cruciate ligament acl reconstruction surgery is one of the most frequently performed operative procedures in orthopaedic surgery.
Aug 26, 2012 injury to the anterior cruciate ligament acl is the most common ligament injury in the knee. Measurements of bone tunnel size in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. This protocol was designed to provide the rehabilitation professional with a guideline of postoperative care. The surgery itself takes about an hour to an hour and onehalf.
1159 622 656 628 254 936 403 547 832 187 130 48 1406 1124 963 1512 608 1494 799 534 945 1249 512 1499 1166 492 780 1525 305 718 846 190 308 1017 752 542 1230 1442 969